Thursday, August 30, 2012

Laying Blame for a Speech Problem

My speech problem began around the time I was twelve years old, in 1960. No one could say then what it was. It didn’t matter that I had grown up as part of a very close community of family and friends. Suddenly, with a voice that was strange sounding and no longer fluent, I knew that I no longer fit in.

When it was obvious that my speech problem wasn’t going away, my mother and I started arguing about it. No one knew what was wrong with my speech, but I never suspected I had anything to do with it. Yet, my mother wound up blaming me for the problem. Although I never fully believed her, I was vulnerable and began to question myself about it. Each time I couldn’t speak, which was almost always, I would think, “Why can’t I do this? Maybe Mommy’s right.”

I moved out of my parent’s house when I was eighteen. My mother protested but I was weary of seeing the look in her face everyday that told me my speech problem was my fault. She never used the word, but I felt like a failure in my mother’s eyes. On one hand it made me very sad, and on the other I knew that her attitude was killing me.

Although I was living on my own, I still spoke with my mother often and she always made me feel like there was something wrong with me. I wanted to get away from her blaming me but instead I turned it on myself. I knew I had to stop seeing myself as a failure and rebuild my confidence, but I didn’t know how. My self-image was so damaged that I began doing drugs and hanging out with the wrong people. I lived like that for two years until I decided, almost on a whim, to move two thousands miles away to California.

It was August 1968 when I moved to Berkeley. Even though it was an opportunity to make a fresh start, I didn’t. I continued to experiment with drugs and developed relationships with others who did the same. This went on for a few years until one evening when I witnessed a horrific drug experience. Someone paid dearly for shooting heroin and what I saw terrified me.

It registered almost instantly that, whatever the reason was for my speech problem, I didn’t want to keep punishing myself for it. I now fully understood that what I saw happen to another drug user could easily happen to me. Almost overnight I stopped doing drugs, dropped all the friends and acquaintances associated to that world, moved to a new place, and decided to finish college. It might have been the first time in my life that I realized how much I cared about myself. Perhaps I had hit bottom and this was the catalyst to finally give myself the nurturing I needed.

A year later I was working and attending college full time. Although I was moving forward and improving myself, I still felt a sense of frustration and failure around my speech. This especially happened each time I spoke with my mother on the phone. Finally, in my thirties and shortly before her death, I noticed that I didn’t even question myself if I felt my mother judging me harshly or blaming me for the unusual way that I struggled to speak. It had taken years but I finally realized that I didn’t have to play the blame game anymore. The endless cycle of her laying blame on me and then laying it on myself was over.

Interestingly, I felt vindicated when I was finally diagnosed and told that I have a severe speech disability. I was fifty-one years old but getting a diagnosis was such an emotional experience that it brought up the blame I had felt so much in the past. There was still a little of it stuck to my soul.

My doctors were very hopeful that treatments and therapy would help me to speak normally again, but the scars left from being blamed for something I never did or created were still there. A part of me still felt unworthy of ever being whole.

In time I was able to speak almost normally and, more than ten years since my diagnosis, I still can. Most of the feelings I accumulated from being blamed for my speech problem have subsided. But, once in a while, if I’m very anxious or scared, that old feeling of unworthiness may surface for a short time. I now put it to bed quickly. I know that it doesn’t belong in my head, and the words of blame laid on me for my speech problem should never have been said.